Artificial Intelligence in Expert Evidence and Reporting

The Role of AI in Expert Evidence and Reporting: Opportunities and Boundaries

Expert witnesses and Solicitors are beginning to use artificial intelligence in their work, but recent judicial warnings make clear that any use must reinforce, not erode, their independence and duty to the court. In some cases, AI is being used to aid document management, summarisation and efficiency. But, as we will discuss in this article, it is important to avoid AI-generated draft reports, opinion‑forming, or legal analysis that could amount to a gross breach of duty or undermine the reliability of expert evidence.

AI in Expert Evidence

Article Summary:

  • AI is increasingly used in expert evidence for document management and summarisation, but not as a substitute for independent expert opinion or judicial reasoning
  • The core framework (CPR 35, FPR 25 and Criminal Procedure Rules 19) still governs expert evidence, with recent AI guidance confirming personal responsibility for all material produced
  • Used carefully, AI can improve efficiency by helping solicitors and experts review large datasets, prepare chronologies and draft clearer instructions
  • Serious risks arise where AI is used to generate draft expert reports, opinions or legal analysis, with an AI‑generated draft expert report condemned as a “gross breach of duty”
  • Solicitors should work with experienced experts who understand both their duties to the court and the boundaries of appropriate AI use, recording any limits on AI in letters of instruction

 

How AI is already being used in the legal sector

Some legal professionals now use private large language models (LLMs) designed for the judiciary, where prompts and case material are not publicly accessible. These are being used for limited tasks such as summarising lengthy expert reports or helping judges orient themselves to complex evidence, but they do not replace judicial reasoning or decision‑making.

In practice, some Solicitors and experts are using AI tools to:

  • Summarise voluminous medical records, reports and technical material.
  • Assist with drafting chronologies, neutral questions, and structured letters of instruction.
  • Organise and search large document sets more efficiently.

Survey data from the Bond Solon Expert Witness Survey indicates that only a minority of expert witnesses currently use AI, albeit a proportion that is growing year‑on‑year. This contrasts with much higher AI use in the wider UK workforce and reflects ongoing uncertainty over the boundaries of appropriate AI use in expert work.

 

Benefits of AI for expert evidence and reporting

When used carefully, AI can offer several practical benefits, including:

  • Rapid summarisation of large datasets, disclosure bundles, and historical records, allowing Solicitors and experts to focus on the key issues and their analysis
  • Faster preparation of case chronologies and working documents can reduce delay and cost for clients.
  • AI-assisted search and classification can help identify gaps or inconsistencies in the material sent to experts, supporting clearer, more targeted instructions.
  • Summaries of expert reports, which are prepared and checked by humans, can assist solicitors in cross-examination planning and in explaining complex evidence to clients.

 

Key risks and recent judicial warnings

At the recent Bond Solon Expert Witness Conference, High Court judge, Mr Justice Waksman, described a solicitor’s insistence on an AI‑generated draft expert report as a “gross breach of duty”. The judge also expressed concern that 14% of experts surveyed would accept instructions accompanied by an AI-generated draft, stating that such conduct was inappropriate even if the expert intended to discard the draft. This warning reinforces the long‑established principle that experts must produce their own independent reports and that solicitors must not seek to shape or pre‑empt those opinions through pre‑drafting, whether by human or AI means.

Judicial guidance specifically warns against using AI to answer the substantive questions experts are instructed on, because this undermines independence and can introduce unverified or fabricated content. Similar concerns apply to AI-driven legal analysis, where “hallucinations” can include non‑existent authorities and misleading interpretations of the law.

If a report or skeleton argument relies on AI-generated content without adequate checking, there is a real risk that the court will view the evidence as unreliable, with potential consequences for admissibility, wasted costs, and professional reputation.

Uploading confidential client information or sensitive case material into public AI platforms also raises obvious confidentiality and data protection risks. In contrast, closed, enterprise-grade systems, like the judiciary’s private AI environment mentioned above, can mitigate some of these risks, provided they sit within robust information security and GDPR frameworks.

Solicitors should continue to use recognised providers and professional bodies to identify experts who are properly qualified, regulated, and trained in their duties under CPR 35, FPR 25 and the Criminal Procedure Rules. It is also recommended to hold pre-instruction discussions to ensure the expert understands their duties and the limits of AI use. As part of these discussions, it is sensible to ask experts whether they use AI, and if so, for what purposes (for example, document management only, not opinion formation). Agreed boundaries can then be recorded in the letter of instruction.

 

Final words

Recent judicial AI guidance (October 2025) from the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary acknowledges that AI tools are now part of the legal environment but emphasises that judges retain personal responsibility for all material produced in their name. Senior judges have warned that AI must not be used in ways that undermine the integrity of the administration of justice or public confidence in the courts.

The most experienced expert witnesses already understand the implications, uses, and boundaries of AI and, where applicable, can explain exactly where it is (and is not) being used.

 

FAQs: Artificial Intelligence in Expert Evidence and Reporting

1. Can solicitors use AI when preparing instructions for experts?

Yes, AI may be used to help structure and draft letters of instruction and chronologies, provided all content is checked carefully and remains consistent with the expert’s duties and the requirements of CPR 35 and FPR 25.

2. Is it ever acceptable to use an AI-generated draft expert report?

No, a High Court judge has described insisting on an AI‑generated draft expert report as a “gross breach of duty”, and experts should not accept pre‑drafted opinions of this kind.

3. How may experts appropriately use AI in their work?

Experts may use AI for administrative and organisational tasks, such as summarising documents and managing references, but should not use AI to answer the substantive questions they are instructed on or to generate their opinions.

4. Can AI be used for legal research supporting expert evidence?

Judicial guidance warns against relying on AI for legal research or analysis because of the risk of hallucinated authorities and inaccuracies; recognised legal research platforms and primary sources should remain the basis for legal work.

5. What are the main confidentiality risks when using AI?

Uploading confidential or sensitive material to public AI tools risks data leakage and potential GDPR breaches; closed, secure systems with appropriate safeguards are safer if AI is to be used with client data at all.

6. Does the court need to be told if AI has been used?

Judges currently have no duty to disclose limited AI use for orientation, and there is no general rule requiring solicitors to disclose AI assistance, but professional obligations mean any document filed must be accurate, reliable, and not misleading, regardless of whether AI played a role.

To instruct an expert witness or to discuss your requirements, please contact Expert Court Reports via their website at www.expertcourtreports.co.uk, by telephone on 01865 587865 or by email at office@expertcourtreports.co.uk.

Google Rating
4.3
Based on 23 reviews
js_loader