The opinion of a midwifery expert witness is likely to be sought when there are concerns that a midwife or another medical professional made a mistake while assisting in the birth of a baby. According to the recently published report entitled, “Listen to Mums: Ending the Postcode Lottery on Perinatal Care” by The All-Party Parliamentary Group on Birth Trauma, 4-5% of women develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) annually after giving birth. This equates to around 30,000 women in the UK, and about a third of women experience birth as traumatic. To underpin the statistics even more, in the past decade, the UK has seen three large-scale investigations into failings in maternity care at Morecambe Bay, Shrewsbury and Telford, and East Kent NHS Trusts, and a fourth investigation is underway at Nottingham University Hospital. Given the impact of birth trauma on the mother and baby and the immediate family, it is extremely important to ensure that any legal representation in criminal and personal negligence court cases is backed up with expert legal insight and opinion.

What can go wrong in birth?
The All-Party Parliamentary Group on Birth Trauma looked at the experiences of 1,300 people who had experienced a traumatic birth and nearly 100 maternity professionals. According to the report:
“The stories told by parents were harrowing. They included accounts of stillbirth, premature birth, babies born with cerebral palsy caused by oxygen deprivation, and life-changing injuries to women as the result of severe tearing. In many of these cases, the trauma was caused by mistakes and failures made before and during labour. Frequently, these errors were covered up by hospitals who frustrated parents’ efforts to find answers”.
The report found a number of key themes:
- Lack of kindness and compassion – according to one person, “The kindness of midwives/nurses where it exists stands out for its rarity – and there were, both times for me, some truly wonderful staff.”
- Poor communication – e.g., not explaining prognosis or procedures, getting names wrong, and staff not understanding important information)
- Failure to listen – e.g. mothers being labelled as ‘anxious’ leading to them not being listened to
- Lack of informed consent – e.g. not explaining tear risks, giving medication or breaking waters without consent, and use of forceps or caesarean suction)
- Lack of pain relief – e.g. being offered paracetamol or being denied an epidural
- Breastfeeding problems – being forced to breastfeed when it is not possible or being made to feel like a failure for not being able to breastfeed
- Poor postnatal care – e.g. little or no support following an emergency caesarean or difficult forceps birth, no help to go to the toilet or lift their baby.
While many of these types of negative experiences may not directly constitute a serious act of medical negligence, they paint a broader picture of what some women are dealing with. It is easy to see why so many people bring claims for midwifery / obstetric negligence.
Time limit to take legal action for midwifery negligence
Another theme raised by the Listen to Mums report related to complaints and claims. Some women who took part in the survey reported they had struggled to take legal action because, by the time they felt well enough to do so, the three-year time limit to bring a clinical negligence claim had passed. One husband who responded explained that he felt as though the hospital involved in the poor care of his wife was “stringing her along for over a year” before eventually admitting liability and agreeing on compensation.
The role of midwifery expert witnesses in birth injury cases
Midwifery expert witnesses have the skills, knowledge, experience, and background to look at even the most complex case of poor midwifery care to ‘join the dots’ to establish if and how negligence occurred. Using case notes, medical notes, correspondence and any other evidence, they create a timeline of events from when the patient started to receive midwifery care up to the current date. To make a successful claim for midwifery clinical negligence, it is essential to establish that a duty of care was owed, that this was breached, and that this caused harm.
Having established what happened, they will seek to understand the physical and psychological harm caused. Where the mother and/or baby have suffered harm, they will assess the impact of the damage and the future prognosis. This information is then collated in the form of an expert report, which is admissible in court and meets the relevant medico-legal guidelines.
Final words
Childbirth in the UK should be a safe and supportive journey for all families regardless of postcode. Sadly, this is not everyone’s experience. Instructing an expert midwifery expert witness to draft an expert witness report can make all the difference in ensuring that an appropriate award is made by the courts that reflects the extent of the damage and loss caused and the future impacts on the mother, baby, and family.
Expert Court Reports provides expert witnesses, and medicolegal court reports for solicitors, barristers and other agencies, including the police, probation services, prisons, third-sector organisations, and private clients. To discuss any issues raised in this article, please call us on 01865 587865, email office@expertcourtreports.co.uk, or request a call by completing our online form.