Article Summary
- Yaser Jabbar, a paediatric orthopaedic surgeon at Great Ormond Street Hospital between 2017 and 2022, harmed 94 children through substandard surgical practice, with 35 suffering severe injuries, including amputations and permanent deformities
- An independent Royal College of Surgeons review found Jabbar performed “incorrect and unsuitable” surgeries, lacked understanding of deformity correction principles, altered clinical records, and systematically hid complications.
- The case exposed profound systemic failures at GOSH, including a dysfunctional department culture where leadership ignored whistleblower warnings for years, allowing harm to accumulate across hundreds of vulnerable young patients.
- For Solicitors representing affected families, expert evidence from qualified paediatric orthopaedic surgeons is essential to establish breach of duty, causation, and long-term prognosis in these complex clinical negligence claims.
- Expert Court Reports provides access to experienced paediatric orthopaedic consultants Mr David Bryson and Mr Matthew Henderson, who offer independent, CPR 35-compliant assessments to assist courts in determining liability and quantum in surgical negligence matters.
Between 2017 and 2022, Yaser Jabbar treated 789 children at Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children. He specialised in limb-lengthening and reconstruction, complex procedures requiring precision, judgement, and an understanding of how growing bodies respond to surgical intervention. By the time an independent review concluded in January 2026, it was clear that 94 of those children had been harmed. Thirty-five suffered severe injuries. At least one child underwent amputation. The case highlights the vulnerability of children in surgical care and the role of independent experts when things go catastrophically wrong.

Background to the case
Yaser Jabbar joined the orthopaedic department at Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) in June 2017, quickly establishing himself as a specialist in procedures involving Ilizarov frames, devices used to gradually stretch and correct bone deformities. These are high-risk treatments, typically reserved for children with complex musculoskeletal conditions.
Surgeon Sarah McMahon, a colleague in Jabbar’s service, reportedly alerted GOSH management to concerns as early as autumn 2021. According to a parliamentary statement by her local MP Dame Meg Hillier, these warnings were not acted upon at the time.
According to GOSH, “Following concerns raised in June 2022, we asked the RCS to review Mr Jabbar’s practice…. restrictions were placed on Mr Jabbar’s clinical practice, and additional support was provided by another experienced Surgeon. Mr Jabbar took an unpaid sabbatical in September 2022 and formally resigned from GOSH in June 2023”.
The RCS initially recommended a focused examination of approximately 200 of Mr Jabbar’s patients; however, GOSH extended the scope to encompass all 789 patients he had treated between 2017 and 2022 to ensure a thorough assessment of potential harm across his entire caseload. In January 2026, GOSH published the findings of its own review entitled “Patient Recall Findings within the Lower Limb Lengthening and Reconstruction Service, part of the Orthopaedic Surgery Department”.
OSH review findings
Expert reviewers identified systematic failures across multiple areas:
Consent and documentation:
Consent forms were “missing, incomplete, or illegible” with “insufficient documentation of alternative treatment options.” Procedures sometimes “differed from what was originally consented to, with no proper record for the rationale for changes.” Records were “brief or incomplete, and lacked essential details such as deformity measurements and neurovascular status.”
Surgical decision-making:
“Inconsistent planning, undocumented day-of-surgery changes, insufficient MDT discussion.” The panel found “limited documentation for complex decision making, with an unjustified preference for certain surgical techniques including unconventional or unrecognised procedures,” alongside “inadequate surgical fixation” and “implants in the wrong place.”
Complication management:
“Delayed or missed identification of serious complications.” Patients’ symptoms were “misattributed to an alternative diagnosis.”
Families dismissed:
“Many families said they were not given clear explanations about treatment options, risks, or why certain decisions were made.” Several “reported raising concerns directly with Mr Jabbar, but they felt these were usually dismissed.”
Culture:
The Royal College review found the orthopaedic department “dysfunctional,” with poor communication and collaboration. Staff raising concerns faced hostility. The hospital operated “like a political organisation” with “outdated,” “unacceptable,” and “hierarchical” consultant behaviour.
Great Ormond Street Hospital has issued a public apology and confirmed it is implementing changes, including enhanced training, improved governance, and mandatory multidisciplinary team oversight for complex cases. The Metropolitan Police are reviewing the report, and Solicitors acting for affected families are preparing claims.
Clinical negligence claims
Clinical negligence claims in paediatric orthopaedics are among the most complex in medical law. Solicitors acting for claimants must establish not only that a breach of duty occurred, but that it caused harm that would not otherwise have occurred, and that the consequences are both quantifiable and enduring. This is where expert evidence becomes indispensable.
Using the Bolam and Bolitho tests, a healthcare professional is not found negligent simply because a poor outcome occurred. The test is whether their actions align with a practice regarded as proper by a responsible body of medical professionals, and whether that body of opinion can withstand logical scrutiny. In paediatric orthopaedics, where surgical decisions involve developing joints and bones, the margin for error is narrow. An expert witness can assess whether the surgery was indicated, whether it was conducted competently, and whether follow-up care met established guidelines.
Causation is often the most contentious element. A child may have had an underlying condition that required intervention. The question for the court is whether the harm they now suffer would have been avoided with appropriate care, or whether it was an inevitable consequence of their original pathology. Expert reports consider hypothetical outcomes, weigh clinical data, and provide clear, evidence-based opinions that assist the court in determining liability.
In cases like those involving Yaser Jabbar, where children are left with chronic pain, restricted mobility, or limb length discrepancies that will affect them for decades, the assessment of quantum is equally demanding. Paediatric orthopaedic experts may be asked to comment on prognosis, future mobility, the likelihood of joint replacements, therapy needs, and the psychosocial impact of permanent disability. These considerations are long-term and must account for life expectancy, ability to work, and ongoing care requirements.
Final words
For legal professionals representing children harmed by Jabbar, the task is to translate complex clinical failures into legal arguments that courts can adjudicate. That work depends on expert evidence that is credible, independent, and grounded in both clinical reality and legal principle. Our paediatric orthopaedic expert witnesses, Mr David Bryson and Mr Matthew Henderson, have the expertise, the integrity, and the medico-legal experience to assist courts in navigating the most challenging paediatric orthopaedic negligence claims. The children harmed by Yaser Jabbar cannot undo the past. But with the right legal representation and the right expert evidence, they can secure a measure of justice and the resources they need to manage the long-term consequences of the harm they have suffered.
Frequently Asked Questions
What legal test applies to paediatric orthopaedic negligence claims?
The Bolam test requires that a healthcare professional’s actions align with a practice regarded as proper by a responsible body of medical professionals. The Bolitho test adds that this body of opinion must be capable of withstanding logical analysis. In paediatric orthopaedics, experts must assess whether surgery was indicated, competently performed, and followed up appropriately.
How do courts establish causation in surgical negligence cases involving children?
Courts must determine whether the harm suffered would have been avoided with appropriate care, or whether it was an inevitable consequence of the child’s underlying condition. Expert evidence is essential to examine alternative treatment pathways, assess clinical data and imaging, and provide clear opinions on what would likely have occurred with competent surgical intervention.
Why is expert evidence particularly important in paediatric orthopaedic negligence claims?
Children’s bodies are still developing, and the long-term consequences of surgical errors may not be fully apparent for years. Expert witnesses must assess not only breach and causation, but also prognosis, future mobility, likely need for additional surgeries, therapy requirements, and the psychosocial impact of permanent disability. These assessments form the foundation for calculating both general and special damages.
What qualifications should solicitors look for when instructing a paediatric orthopaedic expert?
Solicitors should seek consultants who are active in clinical practice, have substantial experience in paediatric orthopaedics, understand medico-legal responsibilities under CPR 35, and have a track record of producing clear, balanced reports that withstand cross-examination. Experience in treating conditions relevant to the case and familiarity with both claimant and defendant perspectives are also valuable.
What changes has Great Ormond Street Hospital implemented following the Jabbar case?
GOSH has confirmed it is implementing enhanced training, improved governance structures, and mandatory multidisciplinary team oversight for complex cases. The hospital commissioned an independent review of all 789 patients treated by Jabbar and has apologised to affected families. The Metropolitan Police are reviewing the findings to determine whether a criminal investigation is warranted.
To instruct an expert witness or to discuss your requirements, please contact Expert Court Reports via their website at www.expertcourtreports.co.uk, by telephone on 01865 587865 or by email at office@expertcourtreports.co.uk.