What is an expert witness in forensic psychiatry?
Forensic psychiatrists are doctors who have specialised in psychiatry and then sub-specialised in forensic psychiatry. They work with individuals who have a history of serious mental illness (such as schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder), neurodevelopmental disorders and personality disorders who are considered to be at an increased risk to others. Generally, patients will have had contact with the criminal justice system and will often have committed at least one serious offence. Forensic psychiatrists many work in the community, inpatient psychiatric units or prisons, and often work across a variety of settings.
Their work may vary from performing psychiatric assessments of individuals at the point of arrest or remand, to supporting and monitoring patients for several years after their discharge/release into the community.

How specialist is a forensic psychiatry expert?
All forensic psychiatrists will have completed an average of five years of medical school, followed by two years of foundation training. Trainees then complete three years of core psychiatry training, before specialising in a particular area of psychiatry.
There are several potential sub specialities in psychiatry, including psychiatry of older adults, child and adolescent psychiatry, medical psychotherapy, intellectual disability, and general adult psychiatry. Higher training in forensic psychiatry takes a minimum of three years however many trainees will choose to complete additional training, such as a master’s degree or research in a particular area of interest.
Forensic psychiatrists are amongst the most instructed expert witnesses, and this is considered a core aspect of their role.
Many forensic psychiatrists who are regularly instructed in expert witness work complete additional training, for example at Gray’s Inn or the Bond Solon certified expert witness training course.
Most forensic psychiatrists have experience of giving evidence at crown court, including in cases where a defendant has been found to be unfit to plead and/or stand trial.
Why might you need to instruct a forensic psychiatry expert witness?
As noted above, forensic psychiatrists are commonly instructed expert witnesses. They may be instructed in a variety of legal proceedings, however criminal cases are particularly considered a core role of the forensic psychiatrist.
In addition to providing comprehensive psychiatric assessments, forensic psychiatrists are often specifically instructed to:
Other incidences where an expert in respiratory medicine may be instructed include:
- Provide assessments of fitness to plead and stand trial according to the Pritchard Criteria following its operationalisation of R v M (John) [2003] EWCA Crim 3452 CA.
- Give opinions on the availability of psychiatric legal defences including the insanity plea and automatism
- Provide a view on the availability of the partial defence of diminished responsibility in cases of murder
- Give opinions about a defendant’s mental state at the material time of the alleged offence or offence
- Opine on the defendant’s capacity to form intent
- Give recommendations on whether an intermediary is required and/or what adjustments to the court process are advisable to aid a defendant’s fitness to engage in proceedings
- Comment on the most appropriate disposal at the point of sentencing, including the appropriateness of hospital orders under section 38, section 37 and section 45A of the Mental Health Act
- Give an opinion on the suitability of restriction orders, under section 41 of the Mental Health Act
Other incidences where a forensic psychiatry expert may be instructed:
Forensic psychiatrists are accustomed to giving psychiatric evidence in a variety of cases. This can include assessing the psychiatric impact of historical traumatic events, for example road traffic accidents, workplace accidents and bullying, and is particularly relevant in cases of historical sexual abuse leading to post traumatic stress disorder. Analysis of potential causation of a psychiatric injury is vital in determining liability and causation in legal claims, and a forensic psychiatry expert witness can be very helpful in demonstrating this to the court.
Forensic psychiatrists may also be instructed in appeals of criminal cases, for example the case of R v Edwards (2018) which provides a precedent for sentencing guidelines when considering hospital orders and hybrid orders under section 37 and section 45A of the Mental Health Act.
As the psychiatrists most commonly involved in the legal system, instructing parties may choose to instruct a forensic psychiatrist in any case including civil, housing, family and immigration cases where mental disorder is potentially relevant.
Why use Expert Court Reports?
A good forensic psychiatry expert witness should come with years of clinical experience as well as specific competencies to act as an expert witness. Look for someone who has established expert witness experience, and preferably additional recognised training relevant to acting as an expert witness. It is also advisable to consider the balance of how often a forensic psychiatrist has been instructed by the prosecution and defence counsel.
Expert Court Reports works with many forensic psychiatrists, all of whom have significant experience of giving evidence in a variety of legal cases. Experts vary in experience and particular areas of interest, enabling instructing parties to make an informed choice of which expert in forensic psychiatry is most appropriate for each case.
How quickly can you provide a report?
At Expert Court Reports Ltd, we understand the pressures of the legal profession. We recognise that litigation is subject to defined timescales and for this reason, we will be as flexible and accommodating as we are able to be. However, we pride ourselves on not promising work that cannot be reliably delivered within a given timescale. The quality of the evidence which is provided by our experts is subject to review and scrutiny. All expert reports are subject to a detailed and robust proofreading process to ensure that our expert evidence is accurate and expertly formatted.
Instructing an expert witness
If you would like to find out more about how our forensic psychiatry expert witness could assist you, please call us on 01865 587865, email office@expertcourtreports.co.uk, or request a quote by completing our online form by clicking the button below.