Obstetrician and Gynaecologist Expert Witness

A speciality that combines aspects of both internal medicine and surgery

What is an obstetrician and gynaecologist?

Obstetrics and gynaecology is an unusual medical speciality in that it combines aspects of both internal medicine and surgery.

Obstetrics is concerned with the care of pregnant women and their unborn children. This includes acute and chronic conditions which may complicate pregnancy and/or birth. Common procedures and interventions include assisted vaginal delivery using forceps or ventouse procedures, caesarean sections (planned or emergency), and surgical interventions following a miscarriage.

waiting room obstetrics and gynaecology.jpg

Gynaecology manages diseases specific to the female reproductive system. It encompasses endocrinology, female urology and pelvic malignancy. Common procedures and interventions include treating abnormal bleeding or polyps, surgery for gynaecological cancers and minimal access surgery, for example in endometriosis.

Obstetrician gynaecologists may also be involved with fertility treatment and prenatal testing.

How specialist are obstetricians and gynaecologists?

All consultants in obstetrics and gynaecology will have completed two years of foundation medical and surgical training, followed by at least seven years of specialty training in obstetrics and gynaecology. Most consultants work within both obstetrics and gynaecology, although it is not uncommon to have more experience in one field than the other.

Some consultant obstetricians and gynaecologists will be considered subspecialists. This indicates that they have completed extra training to attain a higher level of expertise in a certain area of the specialty. The four subspecialties are:

  • Gynaecological oncology
  • Maternal and fetal medicine
  • Reproductive medicine
  • Urogynaecology

Why might you need to instruct an obstetrician and gynaecologist expert witness?

As with any area of medicine things can go wrong, and often obstetrics and gynaecology expert witnesses will be instructed in cases of clinical negligence and personal injury. Expert witnesses are often instructed to provide “quantum reports” to help the court calculate compensation. An example of a case requiring evidence from an obstetric and gynaecologist expert is when infant brain damage may have been caused by a lack of oxygen or failure to monitor the mother and/or baby’s vital signs during labour.

Many examples of cases likely to require expert evidence from an obstetrician and gynaecologist can be found in The Ockenden Report, which found that failures and clinical negligence at Shrewsbury and Telford NHS Trust led to the deaths of more than 200 infants, 9 mothers, and life-changing birth injuries in many more infants. Expert evidence is often required in such cases of catastrophic birth injury to establish the extent of the injuries and the long-term prognosis of the infants and/or mother.

In the case of Crowther v the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, expert obstetric and gynaecological evidence was needed to assist the court by explaining the difficulties clinicians face when distinguishing between foetuses with necessarily fatal abnormalities, and those where significant suffering or long-term impairment may occur.

Other obstetric cases which may require an expert witness include:

  • Prenatal diagnosis
  • First trimester screening
  • Multiple pregnancy complications
  • Labour management (including interpretation of CTGs)
  • Neonatal hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy and cerebral palsy
  • Shoulder dystocia
  • Pregnancy loss
  • Termination of pregnancy without the requisite legal documents
  • Maternal soft-tissue injuries in childbirth
  • Birth injuries occurring during assisted vaginal deliveries.

Gynaecological cases which may require an expert witness include:

  • Gynaecological surgical injuries including:
    • Massive bleeding following surgical procedures such as hysterectomy 
    • Avoidable infertility caused by gynaecological surgical procedures 
  • Management of female urogynaecological disorders including urinary incontinence and prolapse
  • Management of chronic pelvic pain
  • Laparoscopic procedures including diagnosis and management of endometriosis 

What experts does Expert Court Reports have?

We have an experienced and well-respected obstetrics and gynaecology expert witness on our panel. Mr Philip Kaloo is an experienced consultant obstetrician, gynaecologist and laparoscopic surgeon who currently works at The Women’s Centre in Gloucestershire NHS Foundation Trust. He has additional sub-specialist interests in laparoscopic and hysteroscopic surgery, endometriosis, menstrual disorders and the menopause. He is the founder and clinical lead of the specialist endometriosis/pelvic pain clinic in Gloucestershire and the menstrual disorders clinic involving outpatient hysteroscopy.

We also have Mr Mamdouh Shoukrey, he is an experienced consultant obstetrician & gynaecologist, and also an obstetric risk management lead consultant and minimal access gynaecological surgery lead consultant. He is currently based at Dorset County Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. He has been practising obstetrics and gynaecology for over 25 years since his qualification and holds a Master’s Degree in Advanced Gynaecological Endoscopy from the University of Surrey. In his role as Obstetric Risk Management lead consultant at Dorset County Hospital, Mr.Shoukrey investigates clinical risks and medical malpractice. He is also  lead clinician for Minimal Access Gynaecological (keyhole) Surgery at Dorset County Hospital. Whilst there he has introduced new surgical procedures including Total Laparoscopic Hysterectomy and Laparoscopic Resection of Endometriosis.


Why use Expert Court Reports?

A good obstetrician and gynaecologist expert witness should come with years of clinical experience as well as specific competencies to act as an expert witness.  Look for someone who has established expert witness experience.  Our obstetrician and gynaecology experts – Mr Philip Kaloo and Mr Mamdouh Shoukrey have many years of experience both in their clinical fields and as an expert witnesses

How quickly can you provide a report?

At Expert Court Reports Ltd, we understand the pressures of the legal profession.  We recognise that litigation is subject to defined timescales and for this reason, we will be as flexible and accommodating as we are able to be.  However, we pride ourselves on not promising work that cannot be reliably delivered within a given timescale.  The quality of the evidence which is provided by our experts is subject to review and scrutiny.  All expert reports are subject to a detailed and robust proofreading process to ensure that our expert evidence is accurate and expertly formatted.

Instructing a Obstetrician and Gynecologists’ expert witness

If you would like to find out more about how our obstetrician and gynecologists’ experts – Mr Philip Kaloo or Mr Mamdouh Shroukrey could assist you, please call us on 01865 587865, email office@expertcourtreports.co.uk, or request a quote by completing our online form.

View profile